What does it take to make a good Scientist?
I just saw something on the weekly edition of Nature Jobs that made me very happy. It is something that I was waiting to see since a long time. In May 2006 Georgia Chenevix-Trench felt like sharing some of her wisdom with the youngest public of the journal Nature. In the (often embarrassing) portion of the journal called Nature Jobs, she published a Decalogue with “tips for students”; goal of the letter was to provide prospective PhD students with rules of thumbs that would help out having a successful career. Sadly enough most of them were embracing the concept of hard work and only marginally important skills such as creativity, imagination, collaborative science. The author makes the point that only a tiny fraction of enrolled PhD students end up succeeding with a career in Science and propose that the reason might be
we enroll far too many of them without telling them clearly what doing a doctorate should entail. We therefore set ourselves, and the students, on a path of frustration and disappointment.
I won’t say what I think about this idea. Not yet. But I was glad to see an answer today from Sarah Bekessy and Brendan Wintle, two other Australian researchers. Their opinion is very different and definitely less stereotyped.
The idea of a one-size-fits-all model for PhD study is simplistic, patronizing and bad for science.[…] It is a mistake to promote a corporate culture of bulging briefcases, long hours and working weekends as signs of good research practice. PhD students should be judged on their insight and the outcome of their work, not by the number of hours they spend working.
There is no point spending hours and hours in the lab if the only reason of all this hard working is being faster than someone else outside in the world working on the very same project. Think about the great names that made Science: do we remember them because they were faster? Or we rather worship them because of their creativity, their imagination, their ability to think out of the box and see things clearly where other people would see shadow? Not everybody is gifted whit the rare skill of creativity but if there is something you want to work on, then you better concentrate on that. Most of the lab work we do everyday is repetitive, boring and unimaginative. It takes a brain to make a scientists, not just pair of quickly moving hands.